Best Mouse Traps that Capture Mice Humanely & Effectively

Mice Control Traps

A lot of people are concerned about being humane while trapping mice, but also using methods that are effective. When it comes to using mouse traps, you don’t have to sacrifice being humane for it being effective. Here are some of the best mouse traps out there that are both effective and humane to safely and quickly capture mice.

Best Mice Traps for Humane Capturing

Our Top Humane Mouse Trap Picks

There are several different mouse traps that claim to capture the mice humanely, so it might be difficult for you to know which ones are the best. We have compiled a list of three of the best humane mouse traps that you can use to safely and effectively catch mice. These three options are great to use regardless of the situation or where you need to place the traps.

Authenzo No Kill Mouse Trap

The first humane mouse trap we wanted to tell you about is the Authenzo No Kill Mouse Trap, which is both extremely safe and humane. ABS material is used in the design of this trap and there are also air holes in the trap. These holes are important because the mouse will not choke to death and there is no pain inflicted.

With some traps, you will notice the tail is caught in the trap, but not with the Authenzo No Kill Mouse Trap. There is no glue or poison used in the trap, so it’s safe for pets and children to be around. Just use a little bit of peanut butter for bait and then the mouse will be lured into the trap. Once you have caught the mouse, take the trap outside to release him back into nature.

With the Authenzo No Kill Mouse Trap there are many benefits, most of all is the benefit that the mouse is in no way harmed during trapping. The mouse will simply be caught in the trap without losing air or being hurt in any way. This trap uses spring doors, so it will close when there is enough weight, such as the mouse going in to get the bait. It allows you to take the mouse outside for a natural release and it’s not scary or painful to the mouse at all. It’s very safe and humane for the mouse and it’s safe for children or pets to be near as well. The compartments are all removable, which means you can clean it out and reuse it anytime.

There are a couple of cons with the Authenzo No Kill Mouse Trap though that we wanted to tell you about. One of the biggest cons is that this mouse trap uses springs in order to catch the mouse. If the mouse is very lightweight, it might not be enough to trigger the spring, and may not catch the mouse. With heavy mice there are no issues, but very small or baby mice could end up not being trapped due to how lightweight they are. Another con is that it’s fairly small so if you are dealing with a big mouse, such as maybe a pregnant one, it may not fit inside of the trap. So the biggest issues with this trap have to deal with the weight and size of the mouse.

KindTrap Humane Mice Trap

The KindTrap Humane Mice Trap is also one of the best humane traps you can use if you want to humanely but effectively get rid of mice. There is an alarm on this trap which is great at warning you that the trigger has been set off. That means you will not need to constantly keep manually checking the trap and possibly forgetting to get the mouse out. The only thing you will need for the mouse trap to sound the alarm are 2 AAA batteries.

With the KindTrap Humane Mice Trap you will no longer have to worry about checking the traps due to the alarm. There is no poison or glue used in this trap, making it humane and completely safe for the mouse. It’s also safe for children and small pets since there is no poison used. This is a catch-and-release trap that allows you to quickly and painlessly catch the mouse and then release it back outside into the wild.

With this trap you just use a little bit of bait where the back door is and then open the front door. The mouse will trigger the spring and the door will shut, but the mouse will be fine. Once you hear the alarm, head on over to the trap, take it outside and release the mouse. It’s very simple to use and it’s washable so you can keep reusing it when you need it. This trap is also very lightweight and works in virtually any space in your home.

One of the biggest cons of the KindTrap Humane Mice Trap is that it’s made of pretty-easily chewed plastic. There are instances where the mouse can chew the plastic and make the trap stop working. The beeping of the alarm can also scare the mouse, leading to it trying to get out or chewing the device. So while the beeping is good for you, it’s definitely pretty loud and close to where the mouse is trapped. That’s the biggest design flaw of this trap in particular.

Rolling Log Mice Trap

The Rolling Log Mice Trap is one of the best humane mouse traps on the market and it’s the original version that you might have seen on YouTube being talked about by Shawn Woods. With the Rolling Log Mice Trap, you will be able to get the mouse inside of the 5-gallon bucket by using this roller and it will make the mouse fall into the trap quickly. It’s a very lightweight mouse trap and it will work quickly if you use bait to entice the mouse into the trap. The only thing you will need to do is get a 5-gallon bucket and then put the log on the bucket. The mouse will try to get to the bait but end up falling into the bucket instead, so it’s a painless way to get rid of mice quickly.

There are many pros to the Rolling Log Mice Trap including that it’s non-toxic and also not poisonous. You just need to use peanut butter or another type of bait to get the mouse to go onto the roller. You can either put water in the bucket if you want to actually kill the mice or you can use it without water. If you put the roller on a bucket without water, it allows you to catch the mice and then release them back into nature. It’s safe for both pets and children to be around and you can empty your bucket as often as you need to. This is also a reusable trapping method that allows you to use as often as you need to and it’s easy to clean the roller.

There are a few cons with the Rolling Log Mice Trap, such as you might find it tricky to use oil on the roller to get the mouse to fall in. Without oil or something slippery on the rod, the mouse likely will not fall into the bucket. It also seems to be more hit-or-miss when it comes to catching mice. You may catch a few mice using the roller, but you also might not catch them all because it’s a little less reliable.

5 Common Mouse Trap Mistakes

When setting up mouse traps a lot of people end up making some simple mistakes. These mistakes could end up preventing you from catching the mouse or all of the mice you have around your house. Not only that, but some mistakes could be costly to the mouse too. Follow these tips to ensure you are catching and getting rid of mice humanely around your home.

1. Don’t Use Your Bare Hands

It’s really important that when you are using a mouse trap that you are not using your bare hands. You want to use gloves when handling traps and bait. This goes for setting up the trap as well as the release of the mouse. If you use your bare hands the mouse will be able to smell your scent, and that could prevent the trap from working at all. This is one of the most common mistakes and most people aren’t even thinking about this when setting traps.

The mouse will avoid the trap because it smells like you, so wear gloves to ensure human scent is not on the trap. Almost any type of gloves will work, but food gloves are often the cheapest and easiest to get on and off your hands. It’s also important to wear gloves when the mouse is caught to prevent diseases from being transmitted to you from the mouse.

2. Try Different Baits to Attract the Mice

Mice are primarily nut eaters, but sometimes the bait you are using won’t work. It’s important that you try different baits if the first doesn’t work. Peanut butter is the most well-known and also highly-effective bait, but hazelnut spread also works very well at trapping mice. Chocolate is also another type of bait you can try if the two other options haven’t worked out.

There are other kinds of bait you can use such as bird seed and other foods high in fat or high in protein. Small pieces of hot dog can work too, along with maple syrup, bacon bits, and sugary candies like gumdrops. It’s always best to stick with nuts and seeds of some kind, but branch out and try other baits that we’ve mentioned if the normal foods aren’t working.

3. Apply a Small Amount of Bait

One of the biggest mistakes people make when it comes to mice traps is that they think more is better in terms of bait. More bait doesn’t necessarily translate to more success. In reality, you only want to apply a small amount of bait to the trap.

You just want to use a pea-sized amount because you only are looking to entice the mouse into the trap. If you use too much, the mouse might be able to pinch some off and do it without getting caught in the trap. This is a mistake people make often because they think using a lot means that the trigger will be set off, but the opposite actually happens.

4. Use Multiple Mice Traps

You want to widen the scope of the traps by placing several around the house. The chances are that there is more than one mice in the house, so using multiple mice traps ensures you are catching every single one of them.

You want to place a trap every three feet in the area where you know you’ve seen a mouse or mouse droppings. This will help you catch all of the mice and prevent an all-out infestation in your home. There is also the fact that mice reproduce very quickly, often times making seven new babies every three weeks. If you do the math on this, it would take less than a month or two for you to have a huge infestation.

5. Mouse Trap Placement is Important

Where you place the mouse trap is very important because mice don’t like open areas. Mice often stay around the perimeter of your home, such as near the walls and around the baseboards. Concealed areas are where you should be putting the mouse traps because mice will be moving around walls and corners and make them face the wall.

Behind the stove or refrigerator is a great choice, or in the back of a cupboard. Mice use their whiskers to get around environments, so they will want to run around where the whiskers are touching the wall or other surface. That is one reason as to why you won’t see a mouse just running in the middle of your room.

Sam at Organic Lesson

is the Founder of Organic Lesson. He started this site to share tips on using natural remedies at home when such options are available.